Chapter 1 – THE LAST TRAIN HOME
The train doors were already closing when I reached the platform.
“Hold it!”
Nobody held it.
I had a suitcase dragging behind me, a wrapped box the size of a microwave pressed against my chest, and exactly enough dignity left to know I was about to lose all of it in front of several hundred Christmas Eve travelers.
The warning chime sounded.
I shoved the gift box through the narrowing gap and lunged after it.
My suitcase did not cooperate.
One wheel dropped into the space between the platform and the car.
The doors started closing around the handle.
“Oh, come on.”
A hand shot out from inside the train.
A man grabbed the suitcase handle and pulled.
I pulled from the other side.
For half a second, nothing moved.
Then everything did.
The suitcase came free with a violent jerk.
I flew through the doorway.
The doors slammed shut behind me.
The train lurched forward.
And I fell directly into the man who had rescued my luggage.
My shoulder struck his chest. His back hit the side of a seat. The gift box popped open between us, sending silver ribbon, tissue paper, and three glass Christmas ornaments rolling across the floor.
“Oh my God—I’m sorry.”
Someone nearby laughed.
I shut my eyes.
Perfect.
Christmas Eve, 1993, and Claire Bennett had returned home exactly the way she had spent most of her twenties trying not to return anywhere: loudly, late, and carrying too much.
“I’ve got it,” the man said.
His voice stopped me.
He crouched and picked up one of the ornaments.
A little glass cardinal.
My mother collected them.
He turned it carefully in his fingers.
Then he looked up.
He stopped moving.
I stopped breathing.
There were certain faces time was supposed to erase.
Apparently nine years wasn’t enough.
“Claire?”
The platform lights slipped past the windows behind him.
Dark hair, shorter now. A little more weight through the shoulders. A faint line near one eye that hadn’t been there when he was twenty-three.
But unmistakably him.
“Daniel?”
For a moment neither of us did anything.
We had once known everything about each other.
What time the other woke up.
Which side of a booth we preferred.
How Daniel hated raisins but ate my oatmeal cookies anyway.
How I took coffee.
How I went silent when I was angry instead of saying I was angry.
How he rubbed the back of his neck when he was worried.
And then, for nine years, we had known nothing.
Daniel held out the ornament.
“That’s one way to say hello.”
I took it from him.
“I didn’t exactly plan the entrance.”
“You never did.”
Something in the way he said it made the nine years between us suddenly feel much shorter.
I looked away first.
The car was nearly full.
Families. Shopping bags. Winter coats. Children asleep against parents. A college-aged couple sharing headphones from a portable cassette player.
There was one empty seat.
Beside Daniel.
Of course there was.
I considered standing.
Daniel looked at the seat, then at me.
“You can sit down, Claire. I’m not contagious.”
“I was checking whether there was somewhere to put the box.”
“Right.”
I sat.
The ruined bow sagged across my lap.
My suitcase was wedged between my ankles.
Daniel turned toward the window.
I turned toward the aisle.
Neither of us spoke.
The silence had weight.
Not anger, exactly.
History.
Daniel finally glanced at the battered gift box.
“Going home?”
“For Christmas.”
“Just Christmas?”
I looked at him.
“You always ask this many questions?”
“Not usually.”
A beat passed.
“But it’s been nine years.”
I turned toward the window again.
Snow had begun streaking sideways beyond the glass.
“You still live in Connecticut?”
“You still leave before Christmas is over?”
I looked sharply at him.
The words landed exactly where he had aimed them.
Whatever lightness had survived our reunion disappeared.
“You don’t know anything about my life anymore.”
Daniel watched me for a moment.
His jaw shifted slightly.
Then he nodded.
“You’re right.”
That should have made me feel better.
It didn’t.
I opened my mouth, though I wasn’t sure whether I intended to apologize or attack him.
The train screamed.
Metal shrieked against metal.
The car jolted so hard my teeth snapped together.
Someone shouted.
The lights flickered.
A suitcase dropped from the overhead rack.
I was thrown sideways.
Daniel caught my arm.
The next second we were both half in the aisle, his hand braced against the floor, the other arm around my shoulders.
The train shuddered.
Then stopped.
For several seconds, nobody moved.
A baby started crying.
I realized Daniel was still holding me.
He realized it too.
His arm loosened.
“You all right?”
“Yes.”
“You sure?”
“I know when I’m injured.”
“That hasn’t always been true.”
I stared at him.
He almost smiled.
Almost.
We stood and looked through the window with everyone else.
Snow swirled beyond the glass.
Farther ahead, caught in the train’s exterior lights, a large tree had fallen across the tracks.
The conductor’s voice crackled through the speakers.
“Folks, we’ve got a tree down across the tracks. We’re not going anywhere for a while.”
Groans filled the car.
A man behind us asked how long.
Nobody answered.
Daniel looked at me.
“Merry Christmas.”
I laughed despite myself.
It was the first mistake of the evening.
Because once I laughed with Daniel Mercer again, even for half a second, he became harder to hate properly.
We eventually got back into our seats.
For twenty minutes we listened to rumors pass through the car.
An hour.
Three hours.
Another train was coming.
No other train was coming.
They were clearing the tree.
They couldn’t clear the tree until morning.
By the time the conductor announced they were trying to move us to a station farther north, I had decided I needed to relocate.
I picked up my suitcase.
Daniel looked at me.
“Where are you going?”
“Another car.”
“You think the tree is less fallen in coach six?”
“I want somewhere quieter.”
He glanced toward a toddler singing “Jingle Bells” at full volume.
“You may have trouble with that.”
I ignored him.
I dragged my suitcase through the connecting door.
The next car was full.
So was the one after that.
A conductor shook his head when I asked whether there was an open seat.
“Christmas Eve.”
“Yes. I noticed.”
“Try the car you came from.”
I stood in the vestibule for a moment, annoyed at the railroad, the tree, Daniel, Christmas, and possibly the entire state of Connecticut.
Then I returned.
Daniel had not moved.
He had, however, placed my gift box safely on the seat beside him.
He lifted it when he saw me.
“Your throne awaits.”
“I hate you.”
“No, you don’t.”
The answer came too quickly.
His face changed.
Mine probably did too.
I sat down.
Neither of us addressed it.
Twenty minutes later, a railroad employee pushed a small refreshment cart through the car with coffee, tea, packaged crackers, and the sort of sandwiches people bought only when transportation had failed them.
Daniel stood.
“Coffee?”
“I’m fine.”
“You’re freezing.”
“I’m wearing a coat.”
“You’re still freezing.”
Before I could object, he stepped into line.
I watched him from my seat and immediately disliked the fact that I remembered the shape of his shoulders.
Nine years should have erased details like that.
Daniel returned carrying two paper cups.
He handed one to me.
“Two sugars. Little milk.”
I stared at the cup.
Then at him.
He froze.
I hadn’t told him how I took coffee.
Not tonight.
Not in nine years.
Daniel looked at the cup as if it had betrayed him.
“Huh.”
“Huh?”
“I guess I remembered.”
I took it.
“You remembered my coffee?”
“It wasn’t advanced mathematics, Claire.”
“You forgot my birthday once.”
“I was twenty-two.”
“You forgot it by three days.”
“I drove from Hartford to Manhattan at midnight with a cake.”
“The cake said ‘Happy Graduation.’”
“It was the only one they had.”
I smiled before I could stop myself.
Daniel leaned back.
“There. That’s more familiar.”
“What?”
“You making fun of me.”
“I was very good at it.”
“You were relentless.”
The coffee was exactly right.
I hated that too.
The train crawled forward nearly an hour later, moving slowly toward a small station near the Connecticut border where crews could get passengers indoors while maintenance workers cleared the tracks.
By then it was after ten.
The station waiting room was crowded within minutes.
People occupied benches, windowsills, floors.
Children slept beneath coats.
A small artificial Christmas tree blinked near the ticket window.
There were four payphones along one wall.
Each had a line.
I joined the shortest.
Daniel stood several people behind me.
When my turn came, I dropped a quarter into the slot and dialed my mother’s number.
Busy.
I hung up.
Tried again.
Busy.
“Come on, Mom.”
I tried a third time.
Nothing.
Someone behind me cleared his throat.
I turned.
Daniel was watching from his place in line.
“I’m sorry,” I told the people waiting.
I stepped away.
Daniel moved forward, reached the telephone, then held the receiver toward me.
“Try again.”
“What?”
“Use my turn.”
“You’ve been waiting twenty minutes.”
“My father thinks my train is delayed. Your mother probably thinks you’re buried in a snowbank.”
“She usually assumes worse.”
“So call.”
I hesitated.
“You don’t have to do that.”
“I know.”
That was Daniel.
He had always managed to make kindness sound like something practical.
I took the receiver.
This time the phone rang.
My mother answered halfway through the first ring.
“Claire?”
“Mom?”
“Oh, thank God. Where are you?”
“Some station. We had a tree fall across the tracks.”
“A tree?”
“I’m fine.”
“You should have left yesterday.”
“I had work.”
“You always have work.”
I leaned against the payphone enclosure.
“I know.”
“Do you need your brother to come get you?”
“No. They think we’ll be moving again soon.”
I glanced toward Daniel.
He was looking through a newspaper someone had abandoned.
Or pretending to.
My mother kept talking.
Something about tomorrow’s dinner. My aunt. The roads.
Then she said, “At least you didn’t drive. Remember that awful Christmas when Daniel left you and you drove home crying in that terrible little car?”
I went still.
Daniel’s newspaper lowered.
I turned slightly away.
“Mom.”
“What?”
“Nothing. I’ll call when I know more.”
I hung up.
Daniel was staring at me.
Not angry.
Confused.
“What?”
I knew immediately.
“What?”
He stepped closer.
“Your mother thinks I left you?”
I felt something old open inside me.
“Daniel—”
“She thinks I broke up with you?”
“Does it matter?”
“Yes.”
His voice stayed low.
That made it worse.
“My family thought that because that’s what it looked like.”
“To whom?”
“To everyone.”
“You took the job.”
“You wouldn’t leave Connecticut.”
“You never asked me to.”
“I shouldn’t have had to.”
Daniel gave a quiet, disbelieving laugh.
“There it is.”
“What does that mean?”
“It means nine years later and we’re apparently still having the same argument.”
“You’re the one who asked.”
“No. I asked why your mother thinks I walked out on you.”
“Because I came home alone.”
“So did I.”
That stopped me.
People moved around us.
Someone opened the waiting-room door and cold air blew in.
Daniel shoved his hands into his coat pockets.
I said, “Why didn’t you ever correct them?”
“When?”
“You saw my parents afterward.”
“Twice.”
“You could have told them.”
Daniel stared at me for a long moment.
Then he shook his head.
“You were gone, Claire.”
“I moved forty miles away.”
“You moved to New York. Changed your number. Stopped calling. Returned two things I’d left at your apartment through your sister.”
I looked down.
“I was twenty-one.”
“So was I.”
He paused.
“What was I supposed to do? Drive to your parents’ house and explain that technically you had left me?”
“You could have explained what happened.”
“To prove what? That I was right?”
His expression softened, but only slightly.
“You had already decided the story, Claire. You had the new job, the apartment, New York. You didn’t want me following you around arguing about who ended what.”
I remembered December 1984.
The cold apartment.
My first real job offer.
Daniel sitting on the edge of my bed while I packed.
Me asking whether he thought New York was worth it.
Him saying he didn’t know.
I had heard that sentence for nine years.
I had never asked what he meant.
A conductor opened the station door.
“All passengers, please remain inside the waiting room until further notice. We’re still working on the obstruction.”
The room groaned collectively.
Daniel looked toward the snow outside.
Then back at me.
“So.”
“So?”
“Looks like neither of us gets to leave yet.”
For once, I had no answer.
And standing beneath the buzzing fluorescent lights of a forgotten station on Christmas Eve, I began to wonder whether that was the problem we had always had.
One of us had always left before the other finished talking.