Skip to content
DramaDaily

I Caught the Last Train Home on Christmas Eve—and Found the Man I Hadn’t Seen in Nine Years Sitting Inside

Chapter 4 – THE LETTER

My mother waited until Daniel’s car disappeared before turning on me.

“What was that?”

“Christmas.”

“Do not be cute.”

“I’m thirty.”

“You’re my daughter. You’re never too old for me to ask questions.”

She followed me into the kitchen.

“Why was Daniel Mercer driving you home?”

“The train got stuck.”

“I gathered that.”

“We talked.”

“For how long?”

“Apparently long enough for me to abandon my suitcase.”

She stared.

“You lost your suitcase?”

“It’s not lost.”

“Claire.”

“Mom.”

She folded her arms.

The repaired angel sat on the counter.

She had already noticed the ribbon.

“What happened to this?”

“It broke.”

“Daniel fixed it.”

That did not improve the conversation.

My mother sat.

“Did he apologize?”

“For what?”

“For leaving you.”

There it was again.

I opened the refrigerator and stared inside although I wasn’t hungry.

“He says I left him.”

My mother made a dismissive noise.

“He was always stubborn.”

“I moved to Manhattan.”

“For your career.”

“Yes.”

“And he wouldn’t come.”

“He says he was going to.”

My mother became still.

“What?”

“He wrote me.”

“When?”

“December 1984.”

She frowned.

“I don’t remember any letter.”

“Neither do I.”

That should have been the end of it.

Instead my mother said slowly, “There are still boxes downstairs.”

I looked at her.

“What boxes?”

“From your first apartment.”

“I took those years ago.”

“Not all of them.”

Apparently, after I moved from my first Manhattan apartment to a place on West Eighty-Ninth Street, several boxes had come back to Connecticut.

Books.

Winter clothes.

Old mail.

My mother had stored them in the basement because I had promised to sort them “next month.”

Next month became nine years.

We found the boxes beneath Christmas decorations and my father’s old camping equipment.

The cardboard had softened at the corners.

I sat on the basement floor.

My mother handed me envelopes.

Credit card offers.

Old Christmas cards.

A Bloomingdale’s catalog.

A bank statement.

Then I saw the handwriting.

I stopped breathing.

The envelope was yellowed slightly around the edges.

Miss Claire Bennett
317 East 78th Street
New York, NY 10021

The return address was Daniel’s.

The postmark was December 21, 1984.

My mother whispered, “Oh.”

The envelope was unopened.

I held it between both hands.

Nine years.

One sheet of paper had spent nine years in a cardboard box under my mother’s Christmas ornaments.

My entire understanding of my first great heartbreak was sealed inside it.

My mother said, “Open it.”

I stood.

“No.”

“Claire.”

“I can’t.”

“Why?”

Because suddenly reading it alone felt wrong.

Because Daniel had spent nine years believing I had read it and rejected him.

Because whatever those pages contained belonged to the two people we had been.

And maybe to the two people we were now.

“I need to go.”

Daniel answered his father’s phone on the fourth ring.

“Mercer residence.”

“It’s me.”

Silence.

“Claire?”

“I found it.”

Nothing.

Then, “What?”

“The letter.”

Another silence.

Longer.

“You found the letter?”

“It was in a box at my mother’s.”

“Did you open it?”

“No.”

“Why not?”

“I don’t know.”

That wasn’t true.

I held the phone tighter.

“I want to read it with you.”

Daniel breathed out.

“Claire.”

“If that’s ridiculous, say so.”

“It’s not ridiculous.”

“I can come there.”

“No. I’ll meet you.”

“Where?”

We chose a diner halfway between our parents’ houses.

The same diner where we had eaten after my high-school graduation.

It had changed names twice.

The booths were different.

The coffee probably wasn’t.

Daniel arrived wearing the same coat from the train.

I had changed into clothes borrowed from my mother.

He sat across from me.

The envelope lay between us.

Neither of us touched it.

Daniel said, “You really didn’t open it.”

“No.”

“I can tell.”

“I thought you might want to know what twenty-two-year-old you wrote.”

“I’m afraid to know.”

“That makes two of us.”

I turned the envelope over.

“You sealed it with too much tape.”

“I was nervous.”

“You taped a letter shut?”

“I wanted to be certain.”

“You were always suspicious of glue.”

“Claire.”

I smiled.

Then I opened it.

The paper made a soft cracking sound along the fold.

Daniel looked away.

I unfolded the letter.

His handwriting was smaller than I remembered.

I started reading silently.

After the first paragraph, I stopped.

Daniel asked, “Bad?”

“No.”

I swallowed.

“Just young.”

He looked embarrassed.

“Don’t laugh.”

“I’m not laughing.”

I started again.

The letter wasn’t poetic.

That made it hurt more.

Daniel had written that he was proud of me.

That he knew New York mattered.

That he didn’t want me to turn down the job because of him.

He admitted he had been scared when I asked what came next because he didn’t know what came next.

Then he wrote:

I don’t want you to think my not knowing means I don’t want you.

I stopped.

Daniel stared at the tabletop.

I continued.

He wrote that he wanted to try weekends.

Calls.

Trains.

Whatever was possible.

After Christmas, he would speak to a friend of his father’s about work in the city.

He did not promise he would move immediately.

He did not ask me to come back.

He only wrote that if I still wanted him in my life, he wanted to find out whether there was a way to build one that included both of us.

At the bottom:

I love you. I don’t want you to give up New York for me. I only wish you had given me a little more time to figure out how not to lose you to it.

Daniel

I folded the letter.

Neither of us spoke.

The waitress came.

We both said coffee.

When she left, Daniel said, “I sounded less stupid than I remember.”

“You sounded twenty-two.”

“So did you.”

“I didn’t write anything.”

“Exactly.”

I looked at him.

“That was cruel.”

“It was meant to be mildly cruel.”

“It worked.”

The coffee arrived.

I wrapped my hands around the mug.

“I’m sorry.”

Daniel looked up.

“For what?”

“For not knowing?”

“That wasn’t your fault.”

“For never questioning the version I preferred.”

He was quiet.

I continued.

“It was easier believing you wouldn’t come.”

“Why?”

“Because then leaving was brave.”

Daniel leaned back.

“And if I was willing to come?”

“Then maybe leaving without waiting was just leaving.”

He studied me.

“You were allowed to go, Claire.”

“I know.”

“You should have taken the job.”

“I know.”

“I never wanted you to stay because of me.”

“That’s what the letter says.”

“I meant it.”

I laughed softly.

“Nine years later and you’re still refusing to make anything easy.”

“Would you believe me if I did?”

“No.”

We smiled.

Then Daniel asked, “What happens now?”

The question frightened me because I had an answer.

Just not the answer he expected.

I looked down at my coffee.

“There’s something I haven’t told you.”

“That sentence has never gone well for us.”

“My promotion.”

“Yes.”

“It isn’t just a promotion.”

Daniel waited.

“The agency is opening a larger Midwest division.”

His expression changed.

“Where?”

“Chicago.”

“When?”

“January.”

He sat very still.

“They want you to move.”

“Yes.”

“And you’re going?”

“I haven’t signed.”

Daniel looked through the window.

Traffic moved along the snowy road outside.

I had expected anger.

Or irony.

Nine years ago, New York.

Now Chicago.

Instead he said, “Do you want it?”

“I want the job.”

“That wasn’t what I asked.”

“It’s a good opportunity.”

“Claire.”

I stared at him.

He smiled faintly.

“You still do that.”

“Do what?”

“Answer the question that sounds best.”

I bristled.

“I worked twelve years for this.”

“I know.”

“Chicago means vice president.”

“I know.”

“A bigger team.”

“Okay.”

“More money.”

“Claire, I’m not arguing against Chicago.”

“Then what are you doing?”

“Nothing.”

“That’s the problem.”

His expression sharpened.

“No.”

“Yes.”

“No. That was the problem last time.”

I stared at him.

Daniel lowered his voice.

“You wanted me to tell you what to do so you wouldn’t have to own the choice.”

“That’s not fair.”

“Maybe not.”

He sat forward.

“But I’m not doing that again.”

“What does that mean?”

“It means I’m not asking you to stay.”

I felt absurdly hurt.

The feeling embarrassed me.

“You wouldn’t.”

“I won’t.”

“Because you don’t care?”

Daniel’s eyes hardened.

“Don’t do that.”

“What?”

“Make me prove I care by asking you to sacrifice something.”

“I didn’t say sacrifice.”

“You don’t have to.”

I looked away.

Daniel continued.

“Nine years ago, you wanted me to say, ‘Don’t go.’”

I said nothing.

“And part of me wanted to.”

His voice softened.

“But the letter said what I actually believed. I loved you. I didn’t want you to give up your job. I wanted us to figure something out together.”

He nodded toward the envelope.

“I still believe that.”

“Chicago isn’t Manhattan.”

“No.”

“It’s eight hundred miles away.”

“I know.”

“Long-distance didn’t work very well for us the first time.”

“We never actually tried it.”

That landed.

Daniel reached for his coat.

I looked at him.

“You’re leaving?”

“I think you need to decide what you want before we turn this into another argument about me.”

“So that’s it?”

“No.”

He stood.

“That’s exactly the point.”

I stood too.

Daniel looked at me.

“Go to Chicago if you want Chicago.”

“And if I don’t?”

“Then don’t.”

“That simple?”

“No.”

He smiled sadly.

“Simple and easy aren’t the same thing.”

I folded my arms.

“You won’t ask me to stay.”

“No.”

“Not even now.”

“Especially now.”

“Why?”

Daniel looked at me for a long time.

“Because if there’s going to be anything between us again, Claire, I need to know you chose it awake.”

The words hit harder than any declaration could have.

He picked up his coat.

At the door, he turned.

“Decide where you want your life to be.”

Then he left.

I sat back down.

The old letter remained on the table.

Nine years ago, Daniel had written that he didn’t want me giving up my future for him.

Now he was telling me the same thing.

The difference was that this time, I had heard him.

And for the first time in my adult life, I had no one to blame for the choice but myself.