Skip to content
DramaDaily

I Caught the Last Train Home on Christmas Eve—and Found the Man I Hadn’t Seen in Nine Years Sitting Inside

Chapter 2 – WHAT WE REMEMBER

My mother’s Christmas present had cracked straight through the middle.

I discovered it while trying to rewrap the box on a station bench.

The gift was a ceramic angel she had admired in a shop window in Manhattan two months earlier and then refused to buy because, according to my mother, thirty-eight dollars was “highway robbery for something that sits on a shelf.”

One wing had broken cleanly away.

“No.”

Daniel looked over.

“What happened?”

I held up the wing.

“I killed Christmas.”

“That seems dramatic.”

“It’s my mother’s gift.”

“She has others.”

“You don’t know my mother.”

“I dated you for four years. I absolutely know your mother.”

He took the angel from me before I could object.

“It’s a clean break.”

“You’re an expert now?”

“My father repairs furniture. I grew up around glue.”

“That’s not the same thing.”

“No, but neither one of us has ceramic adhesive.”

He glanced around the station.

“I can make it presentable.”

“With what?”

Daniel walked to the little artificial tree.

Paper chains and ribbon had been taped around the ticket window.

I followed.

“You’re not stealing station decorations.”

“I’m borrowing them.”

“That’s stealing with Christmas vocabulary.”

Daniel peeled off a piece of clear tape.

A railroad employee watched him.

Daniel held it up.

“My friend broke her mother’s Christmas present.”

The employee looked at me, then at Daniel.

“Merry Christmas.”

“See?” Daniel said.

“Official permission.”

We sat on the floor beside the bench because every seat was taken.

Daniel fitted the wing against the angel carefully and secured it with thin pieces of tape.

I watched his hands.

They looked older.

That shouldn’t have surprised me.

Mine did too.

He had a small scar near his thumb.

“You cut yourself.”

He looked down.

“This?”

“Yes.”

“Table saw.”

My eyes widened.

“Relax. It was nine years ago.”

“You could have mentioned the saw before telling me.”

Daniel smiled.

“There she is.”

I looked away.

“What?”

“You used to worry about things five years after they happened.”

“I was trying to make conversation.”

“Sure.”

He tied silver ribbon around the angel so the knot concealed the repair.

It was imperfect.

But sweet.

Annoyingly sweet.

I put it back into the box.

“Thank you.”

“You’re welcome.”

We sat there for a moment.

Then I asked the question before I thought better of it.

“Does your wife know you spend Christmas Eve repairing gifts for women from your past?”

Daniel looked at me.

“My wife?”

I immediately wanted to disappear.

“I just assumed.”

“That I was married?”

“You’re thirty-one.”

“So?”

“So nothing.”

He waited.

I concentrated on flattening tissue paper.

“You seemed like someone who would get married.”

“That’s a terrible reason to get married.”

“You know what I mean.”

Daniel folded his arms over his knees.

“I never did.”

I looked at him.

“Never?”

“No.”

“Oh.”

He raised an eyebrow.

“Disappointed?”

“Why would I be disappointed?”

“I don’t know. You sounded surprised.”

“I am surprised.”

“Why?”

Because I had pictured it.

Not often.

But sometimes.

Daniel with a wife in a yellow kitchen somewhere in Connecticut.

Children.

A dog.

Christmas cards.

The entire ordinary life I had told myself I didn’t want.

“I just thought you probably would.”

Daniel looked toward the windows.

“I came close once.”

Something moved in my chest.

“Oh.”

“But it didn’t happen.”

“I’m sorry.”

“I’m not.”

He said it simply.

I couldn’t tell whether he meant it.

I asked, “Why are you going home?”

“My father had surgery.”

I straightened.

“What happened?”

“Heart bypass in November.”

“Daniel.”

“He’s doing well.”

“You should have told me.”

The words escaped before I could stop them.

Daniel’s expression changed.

“Claire.”

“I mean—”

I looked down.

“Obviously you wouldn’t have told me.”

“No.”

A beat.

“But I would have wanted to.”

That was worse.

He rubbed his hands together.

“I’m staying with him through the weekend. My sister’s there too. Her kids have probably destroyed the house already.”

“You have nieces and nephews?”

“Three.”

“How old?”

“Eight, six, and four.”

“You’re an uncle.”

“I’ve been one for eight years.”

“You were always good with kids.”

“You hated kids.”

“I did not hate kids.”

“You told my cousin Jeremy he was an argument for boarding school.”

“He poured orange soda into my purse.”

“He was five.”

“He knew exactly what he was doing.”

Daniel laughed.

It was the same laugh.

That was unfair.

People changed.

Teeth changed. Hair changed. Jobs changed. Addresses changed.

Some sounds apparently didn’t.

Eventually he asked about me.

“So what’s the famous Claire Bennett life?”

“Famous?”

“You left for New York like you were invading Europe.”

“I did not.”

“You had a five-year plan.”

“I was organized.”

“You color-coded it.”

“That was one notebook.”

“What happened?”

“To the notebook?”

“To the plan.”

I leaned back against the bench.

“I’m still in Manhattan.”

“I gathered that.”

“Advertising.”

“I know.”

I looked at him.

“How?”

“Your mother told my father years ago.”

Of course she had.

“She talks about you like you run Madison Avenue.”

“That sounds like her.”

“Do you?”

“Not yet.”

I smiled.

“I’m a senior account director. There’s a promotion coming after New Year.”

“That sounds impressive.”

“It is.”

“And?”

“And what?”

Daniel watched me.

“Nothing.”

“What?”

“You just gave me your résumé.”

“You asked about my life.”

“I asked about you.”

“That is me.”

His expression said nothing.

I hated that expression because it was the one that used to make me hear my own answers differently.

“I have a good apartment.”

“Okay.”

“Twentieth floor. East Side.”

“Doorman?”

“Yes.”

“I’m impressed.”

“You sound sarcastic.”

“I’m not.”

“I travel. Boston, Los Angeles sometimes. Chicago.”

“Good.”

“I’m good at what I do.”

“I never doubted that.”

“Then why are you looking at me like that?”

“Like what?”

“Like you’re waiting for me to finish.”

Daniel was silent.

Then he said quietly, “You never said whether you like your life.”

I laughed.

“What kind of question is that?”

“A regular one.”

“I just told you I have a great career.”

“I know.”

“And an apartment.”

“I heard.”

“And friends.”

“You didn’t mention friends.”

“I have them.”

“Good.”

I stared at him.

He stared back.

I finally said, “Yes. I like my life.”

Daniel nodded.

“All right.”

But something about the conversation followed me.

An hour passed.

The station grew quieter as tired passengers stopped complaining and surrendered to the delay.

A radio sat on a shelf behind the ticket window.

Someone turned it louder.

A Christmas song began.

The first notes were enough.

I stopped mid-sentence.

Daniel stopped too.

“I’ll Be Home for Christmas.”

The song had played the last Christmas we spent together.

1984.

We had been in Daniel’s old Buick outside my parents’ house.

The heater barely worked.

Snow had been gathering along the windshield.

I had already accepted the Manhattan job but hadn’t told my parents.

Daniel had known.

We had sat there listening to the radio after midnight.

Neither of us wanting to say goodnight because saying goodnight meant admitting something larger was coming.

Now the song drifted through a railroad station nine years later.

Daniel looked at the radio.

I looked at the floor.

Neither of us mentioned the memory.

That made it more present.

When the song ended, I said, “You never wanted New York.”

Daniel looked at me.

We had been circling the subject for hours.

Apparently it was time to stop.

“You still believe that?”

“You said you didn’t want to live there.”

“I said I didn’t know if I wanted to live there.”

“You said you wanted to stay near your father.”

“I did.”

“That’s the same thing.”

“No.”

“It felt the same.”

Daniel sat forward.

“You got the job offer on Monday. By Wednesday you had signed a lease.”

“I had to answer.”

“You told me after you had already decided.”

“I asked you.”

“You asked whether I was excited.”

“You weren’t.”

“I was terrified.”

I stared at him.

Daniel continued.

“You had this whole new life opening up. I had just started working with my father. My mother had been gone less than two years. My sister was still in school.”

“I knew that.”

“No, you knew the facts. You didn’t ask what I wanted to do.”

“You never said.”

“Neither did you.”

“I told you I wanted New York.”

“You told me you were going to New York.”

“That’s different?”

“Yes.”

His voice remained quiet.

“That’s exactly what was different.”

People nearby were sleeping.

We lowered our voices.

I said, “You told me you couldn’t promise anything.”

Daniel nodded.

“I remember.”

“What was I supposed to hear?”

“That I was twenty-two and scared.”

“You think I wasn’t scared?”

“No.”

“Then why didn’t you say you would come?”

“I almost did.”

I looked at him.

“What?”

Daniel rubbed the back of his neck.

The old gesture.

“I was ready to try it.”

“When?”

“After you moved.”

I stared at him.

“That makes no sense.”

“I needed about a week longer than you gave me.”

“A week?”

“You left on December eighteenth.”

“I had to start work.”

“I know.”

“You didn’t call.”

“I did call.”

“Once.”

“Twice.”

“I called you back.”

“After three days.”

“I was working twelve-hour days.”

Daniel exhaled.

Then he said, “I wrote to you.”

The station seemed to go quieter.

“What?”

“A letter.”

I almost laughed.

“You wrote me a letter?”

“Yes.”

“You never wrote letters.”

“I know.”

“When?”

“After you moved.”

I searched his face.

“What did it say?”

Daniel looked away.

“It doesn’t matter.”

“You just told me you wrote it.”

“It was nine years ago.”

“What did it say?”

He hesitated.

“That I wanted to try long-distance.”

My chest tightened.

“And?”

“That after Christmas, I was going to start looking for work in the city.”

I stared at him.

“No.”

Daniel frowned.

“What do you mean, no?”

“I never got that.”

“I mailed it.”

“To where?”

“Your apartment.”

“Which apartment?”

“The place on Seventy-Eighth.”

I felt cold.

“I never received it.”

Daniel looked at me with an expression I had never seen on him before.

Not anger.

Not suspicion.

Confusion.

“I addressed it myself.”

“I’m not saying you didn’t.”

“You lived there.”

“For four months.”

“You were there in December.”

“Yes.”

“Then you got it.”

“No.”

“Claire—”

“I would remember a letter from you.”

“You returned my sweater.”

“My sister returned your sweater.”

“Exactly.”

“I never got a letter.”

Daniel sat very still.

The radio changed songs.

Outside, workers moved along the platform with flashlights.

I asked, “Did you ever wonder why I didn’t answer?”

“For a while.”

“And?”

“And then I figured your silence was the answer.”

I felt something inside me drop.

“What did you do?”

“Nothing.”

“You didn’t call again?”

“I called once in January. Your number had changed.”

“My building switched lines.”

“I didn’t know that.”

“You could have called my parents.”

“And say what? ‘Your daughter hasn’t answered my letter, can I have her new number?’”

“Yes.”

Daniel smiled without humor.

“Twenty-two-year-old me had more pride than that.”

“So did twenty-one-year-old me.”

We sat in silence.

For nine years, I had carried one version of our ending.

Daniel had been afraid of New York.

I had chosen my future.

He had let me go.

He had carried another.

I had chosen New York.

He had offered to try.

I had ignored him.

Neither story was entirely true.

Neither was entirely false.

A conductor entered the room.

“All right, folks. Track is clear. We’ll be boarding again in ten minutes.”

Everyone began collecting luggage.

Daniel stood.

He picked up my repaired gift box and handed it to me.

Neither of us spoke about the letter.

But something had changed.

Nine years of certainty had developed a crack.

And I no longer knew what was on the other side of it.